We Make

Our agents have assisted seniors for over 25 years in Indianapolis, Fishers, Plainfield & Fort Wayne.

Save yourself time and headaches from researching confusing Medicare options with our free consultation!

Small & family operated means a unique, personal touch to the client experience.​

We partner with a wide variety of carriers to match your healthcare needs.​

Building Relationships with Seniors for 25 Years

Jess and Sandra, co-founders of Easy Street Insurance, have earned the trust of thousands of seniors across central Indiana. As an independent Medicare broker, we represent many of the top-rated insurance carriers and provide our clients with plans that fit their individual needs. We take the time to explain all your options in a simple and concise manner.

Our licensed agents are ready to help you navigate the ever changing world of Medicare.

0 +

Seniors Trust Our Medicare Agents

Medicare plans are constantly changing. You can count on our agents to be here for you.
0 +

Carriers Represented

We stay up to date with the most trusted carriers for every Annual Enrollment Period.
0 +

Research Hours Saved per Client

Time is valuable. Our services are at no cost, so take advantage of our experience!

We go the extra mile to make sure you understand every aspect of Medicare.

Sandra Carrasquillo

Jess Carrasquillo

Avery Miller

Julie Corcoran

Justin Kozlowski

No Cost. No Pressure. Just Sound Advice!

100+ Google Reviews!

Phil and Lucy

One of the many things my wife and I have always appreciated about Easy Street Insurance is their willingness to help and make sure we have the insurance that best fits our needs. We have been pleased working with Easy Street for 10 years, and it is a pleasure to praise a company that is as helpful and professional as they are.

Dean Jones

When I turned 65 there was no other person or no other people to turn to but to Sandra and Jess!! We deeply appreciate the continued, outstanding customer service – getting questions answered whenever a need arises and feeling the support and the availability of the entire Easy Street staff. They handle each situation with professionalism and class.

Ben and Karen

We want to give a heartfelt thank you to Easy Street. We were having trouble getting our Medicare Advantage Plan provider to pay a dental claim. Easy Street contacted them for us and found us even more savings than expected. It was easy to see that they truly cared about solving our problem.